top of page

Discussions

Discussion‑based assessments (DBAs) are structured, real‑time conversations between a learner and an instructor that evaluate understanding through dialogue rather than traditional testing formats.

Group Discussion

For designers and educators, DBAs create space for learners to explain their reasoning, ask clarifying questions, and demonstrate conceptual understanding in a supportive, conversational environment. They also offer an authentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) resistant way for learners to articulate ideas in their own words, giving instructors immediate insight into genuine comprehension and thought processes.

 

  • DBAs are particularly effective in online, blended, and competency‑based settings, where academic integrity, learner presence, and real‑time thinking are essential components of assessment.

  • ​DBAs strengthen communication skills, deepen conceptual understanding, and allow for highly personalized feedback.

  • DBAs can introduce challenges such as learner anxiety or scheduling constraints.

  • High‑quality DBAs rely on clear expectations, intentional prompts, and alignment with learning outcomes to ensure the conversation remains focused, equitable, and instructionally meaningful.

  • When thoughtfully designed, discussion‑based assessments support multimodal expression and offer a more holistic, human‑centered view of learner mastery.

​

Strengths

  • Stengthens communciatiopn skills

  • Deepens conceptual understanding of content

  • Personalized and immediate feedback

  • Flexible and inclusive​

  • Enhanced reflection and critical thinking

  • Holistic evaluation

Challenges

  • Increases learner anxiety

  • Scheduling constraints

  • Insecurity among individual students​

  • Time consuming

  • Confusing in large group situations

  • Inability to monitor all learners

  • Potential for interruptions

Team Meeting Discussion
Discussion-based Assessment: Example

Context: Unit Mastery Check in an Online Adult Education Course

In an online adult education course, the instructor schedules a 10‑minute discussion‑based assessment at the end of each unit.

During the session, the learner explains key concepts, such as workplace communication strategies or problem-solving processes, while the instructor asks follow‑up questions to probe reasoning and clarify misconceptions.

The learner may reference notes, but the focus is on verbal explanation, real‑time thinking, and applied understanding, consistent with Florida Virtual School guidance that DBAs verify comprehension and allow students to ask questions about the content.

The instructor uses a rubric to evaluate clarity, accuracy, and application of concepts, and provides immediate feedback to support next steps.

This format strengthens learner confidence, supports academic integrity, and offers an alternate, low‑stakes space for demonstrating mastery.

​

Explore the following resources for more information:​

​​

​​

​

bottom of page